On a
'Garden Leader' (from kerb to premises), it's common-place to perform a pair-swap if the new pair tests OK. It saves potential ground-works on the EU's premises (anything from a small garden front, to a palatial spread). This is in regard to
'Direct in ground' (Armoured) cable
It's rare for a
'Ducted cable' to have a faulty pair, I've personally only known one, which was down to a rat chewing on it. There is always the very rare occasion that there could be split-pairs (Causing poor AC Bal), but this doesn't seem to be what the forum member is talking about ?
However you want to view it, we weren't there on-site and not privy to the full details and as such, any comments are pure speculation and personal opinions only.