tubaman is correct. I’ve never managed to measure any difference between all the really top ones and any of them vs none at all. The good ones that I have used are (note ADSL-only) ADSL Nation one and the BT Pressac type ones. The latter are excellent. The ADSL Nation active ones are good but perhaps more relevant in the case where you have other kit such as one or more telephones attached also. Top tip: absolutely
do not have other kit such as one or more telephones attached also. And remember that these observations were made with ADSL2 only and with an ultra-sensitive setup, because it’s with ultra-long lines in use, approx 4.55 miles long, hence an ultra-weak signal received ( ~64 dB attenuation downstream). (Too many ‘ultras’ [ed.])
Indeed getting rid of telephones and extensions helps you get the very best out of your line. That’s always what you should do unless you’re absolutely
forced to have a telephone on the same line.
I refer you also
Burakkucat’s warning earlier about
not using these abovementioned filters with FTTC/VDSL2 lines. They’re only for ADSL2 lines.
Those old ADSLnation centralised filters were designed for ADSL/ADSL2+ as that was only what existed "back then".
For ADSL, the ADSL Nation’s advantage is that it’s cleverly designed to cover up the differences between the on-hook and off-hook situations so that you should not see any transient problems when you transition between the on- and off-hook states, or have DSL performance problems while you are on the phone.
For FTTC/VDSL2 lines, use no filter, unless you for some reason have to have a telephone on the same line. If you do have to have a telephone then I strongly recommend following J0hn’s advice:
I'd recommend an OpenReach MK3 SSFP if you have an NTE5A master socket.
If you have the newer rounded NTE5C them buy an OpenReach MK4 that fits the newer master sockets.
I agree with J0hn and much prefer the NTE5A/Mk3 SSFP from Openreach (optimal solution), preferred by both me and J0hn over the modern NTE5C/Mk4 SSFP - the one with rounded corners. The NTE5C/Mk4 SSFP combo disconnects without screws, which is nice, but they don’t seem like a very secure fit.
I myself ended up with one NTE5C+Mk4 SSFP, the new Openreach installation default, after a recent line installation, unfortunately. I was initially forced to have an unnecessary SSFP that way, which is bad. And that was my fault for not sitting there watching the engineer’s every move like a hawk. I immediately wanted to get some help in order to follow J0hn’s recommendation and put it back the way it was, with an NTE5A+no filter.
If you don’t have to have a telephone, then hallelujah: you can also get a perfect solution, which is an Openreach telephony-only NTE - not sure exactly what it’s called, and no filter. This Openreach package comes as an NTE5c back-box, I think, but with a telephony front lower-half plate that has a BT telephone socket / old UK dialup modem socket in it. Then to make it work you just need an old-fashioned dialup-modem cable that is UK-BT-phone plug (into wallsocket) to RJ-11 plug (modem end).
Cables and plugs: Some dialup modems did come with a cable that had UK BT plugs on the end, perfect for the above solution, apart from usually being way too long for the typical modern use-case where we want the cable to our modem to be short to keep interference to a minimum. Carefully read the spec for the dialup-modem cable though, as some dialup modem cables do however come with the wrong, so-called ‘US’ plug, ie RJ-11 plugs on both ends. So watch out. The RJ-11 sockets were sometimes called ‘american modem sockets/plugs’ back then.
I should ask the grumpy old cat what the correct technical terms are for the plug types needed?
I would prefer getting a lead made up that has the correct plugs in it as it’s going to hopefully be more robust and be cleaner than the above converter plug, which is however fantastic value. I got someone on ebay iirc to make up cables for me with the right plugs on them. Could even look at Amazon shops maybe. Getting a custom-made one you can have it exactly the right length, can specify high-quality gold-plated plugs on it of the type you need, and high-quality twisted-pair
BT CW1308 cable used by Openreach for doing phone extension cables. This latter is very important. It’s also important, mainly with ADSL, to keep the cables short, just long enough to reach the modem as this minimises interference pickup within the home/office. Mine are ridiculously short, 0.5 / 1.0 / 2.0 m as short as we can get away with. If you have a separate modem and router, which is a great idea, then you can keep the modem near to the wallsocket and make the modem-router ethernet cable as long as you like.
So coming back to plugs: depending on which of the various solutions above you choose, you need either an RJ45-RJ11 cable, or a dialup-modem-to-UK-BT-phone plug.
To be honest, with VDSL2 none of the micro-optimisation things such as NTE / SSFP choice, or cable length or whatever is going to make much difference to performance. It’s especially unimportant (too many negatives, [ed.]) if you’re using FTTC/VDSL2 and you’re very close to the FTTC ‘green cab’, because a very short line means a strong signal received at your end, and you are much, much less sensitive to interference including interference pick-up within the home/office even, because your received signal voltage at your line will be comparatively really high, so large compared to any local in-house noise.
If you’re using ADSL, then every little thing matters, how much depending on how long your copper phone line is from the exchange.
But if you have an interference problem in your home or office where your wallsocket-modem cable is picking up RF noise, make sure you are using CW 1308 cable, keep it short and keep it well away from mains cables and any electrical equipment. If you have to cross a mains cable, don’t, but if you have a gun to your head, cross the cables at right-angles and try and keep the two well spaced apart. Try relocating cables and kit. Do not run mains cables and modem cables parallel alongside each other, or worse parallel close together and worst of all touching.