Why shouldn't I give up?
Well, I have had problems with my ADSL for a while. Issues have cleared because I kept pestering my ISP!
When I switched to LLU with Tiscali all hell broke loose with my ADSL and I only synced at 4563kbps on a 30dB attenuation. I came here for help and after many months of constantly arguing Tiscali they removed a speed cap on my line, but I still only synced at 6000kbps.
After totally re wiring the house and using the Radio trick to check for interference I now manage a sync of 7648kbps.
Your stats in your op show that you have a lot of CRC errors which are caused by Noise Impulses. Lots of these will affect throughput.
Have a go at the
Radio Trick. It showed me how the old boiler was playing havoc! A new one and the improvement came (some what!)