Does QoS work even if your modem-router is set to just be a modem? Or does it only apply to routers being routers?
AA send out ZyXel VMG 1312-B10A with QoS set to prioritise small packets even when the device is already preconfigured in modem-only mode. I wonder if this is intentional or just a commonality with the config they use for routers set up as routers, which they do also ship.
I was thinking about how to test it. I thought the Firebrick prioritises short packets so that would muck up testing surely.
There is a but though.
If the Firebrick is set up to limit upstream traffic rates to something just below what each modem can handle when maxed out, set by calculation that is hopefully accurate and wisely chosen, then it will be the Brick that is in control surely, and the Zyxel modem will not get a chance to apply its QoS as packets will always arrive slightly too late. That is my thinking anyway. Is that correct?
Anyway, if that is right, then it will invalidates my tests because the Firebrick is what is being tested, not the ZyXel. Could fix it though, by putting the speed rates way way up in the Brick.