Returning to the ‘first look’ theme of this thread properly, I have to say how impressed I am with this B10A modem. I didn't even know what I was getting and it turns out I’ve got a lot more than I ever knew.
*Monitored tones. It looks like this modem has the monitored tones feature. Is that correct? I take it the DLinks did not have such capability but I don’t know why I say that and I can’t be sure. It seems to me essential anyway, never mind the cost, otherwise you could be on a downward slide over time heading inexorably to an eventual resynch. Is that correct? If my understanding is correct then not having it means a setup that is not sustainable long term and will have a definitely limited connection lifetime. I assumed that I would get this.
* PhyR - I had forgotten about the very existence of this, didn’t know it had been deployed in BT 21CN, assuming that my understanding is correct, and didn't know who the mfr of the DSLAM at the NSBFD exchange was, which is crucial because I believe this is a Broadcom-to-Broadcom only thing? So if I have got this right then an extremely pleasant surprise - big reliability boost and possibly a speed boost too.
* Latency is reduced for some reason. Perhaps this is to do with an indirect consequence of having PhyR. I have a very low downstream interleave D value (see G.992.3) of only 2 (unfortunately). I don't know why but perhaps some software somewhere has decided that given the presence of PhyR then I am adequately protected against burst noise/spikes even with a low D value. Could that be right?
* And just plain speed: an extra downstream 200-400kbps compared with the DLink modems, and at a higher actual SNRM too, so the speed would be even higher if I could make the SNR values the same. Unfortunately on the one line I've tried, the upstream is 10% worse, 515 kbps instead of 566 kbps before.
* Stability: the SNRM downstream is not all over the place, starting out lower than the target and then drooping much further before wobbling up and down slowly, sometimes ending up down at 0.6 dB downstream from a 3 dB downstream target. Upstream is unchanged at a controlled and stable 6 dB staying close to the 6 dB upstream target.