Proof of concept is an interesting phrase to use, to me that implies perhaps a trial or partial roll out rather than full roll out for all? Why didnt they use the word trial?
I wonder how many lines would possibly support this without G.INP. Not many I imagine, mine in its current state certainly wouldn't.
It will be interesting to see how kitz' and Chrysalis' circuits behave with a lower target SNRM.
Theoretically mine should. Its run perfectly fine in the past for for several weeks at 3dB after resyncing before my crosstalker(s) without it causing an increase in the error rate. What currently upsets the apple cart on my line is the morning blip of errors that sometimes gets stuck until I perform a manual resync. If I don't catch it quick enough DLM spots it.
3dB should take my line back up to near 80Mbps sync. If it wasn't for that daily blip I'd be fine. I ran at 3dB for many years on BE* without issue.
True but lines with high es will be a real mess if it's not carefully controlled 😃 (like mine)
If DLM was working how it should then, it should back off back to 4db > 5dB > 6dB. However they did a botch job of capping after ASSIA, which doesnt appear to like backing down again even if the line is stable.
The DLM process needs a total review on the steps it takes, the original NGA process seemed to work OKish. The botch job on NGA after ASSIA and a a further botch for G.INP has complicated things. As Ive said before, unfortunately I dont see them doing any review whilst the 2 [cab type] systems have different processes.
The main difference with the NGA system process is that it uses capping to a much greater extent than the 20/21CN systems. It is clear from the court case documentation that ASSIA's main complaint was with the NGA DLM and reading between the lines there was suggestion that it may be with the ILQ, which in turn infers how it returns back to normal.
If they ever get G.INP on ECI and they do start using 3dB, then IMHO it would be best if they abandoned capping and returned to the tried and trusted target SNRM which works fine on 21CN. 3dB also works fine for many lines on 21CN, the mess with NGA is that lines get stuck with a cap far too easily.
