I'm still old school with a written list, obviously with a title that is nothing do do with password etc but also does not contain any banking information, that's still down down to pen and paper.
I just checked my written list (excel sheet) of sites requiring a password and the count is 88 (I think that's all of them), I find it convenient because it also has a link to the site, so in a way it's a bit like having your list of favourites complete with passwords all in one place.
Not forgetting one of the main problems I don't think is forgetting ones password, but more likely to be not remembering the correct user name, because if the username you would like to use has already been taken then you have to chose something with a slightly different format, even my 'oldfogy' has been rejected on some sites simply because at some stage someone else decided to use it, and much the same as with 'Phil-H, Phil_H, phil-h, phil_h, ........... the combinations are endless