Kitz Forum

Chat => Chit Chat => Topic started by: tickmike on November 02, 2013, 07:29:40 PM

Title: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: tickmike on November 02, 2013, 07:29:40 PM
You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.  :o
I Did  ;D

My water meter battery failed only after 7 years (according to the meter date it was 10 years old before it was fitted  :hmm: ) and the meter reader could not get a reading from the outside touch pad .
I had a letter saying they need to replace the meter and they would fit a 'Smart Meter with Radio sender' so they could just read it from outside in the lane.
I sent them an email saying.
I Will Not Have A Smart Meter and they could change it like for like.
I was surprised when they said ok you do not have to have a smart meter but they had none of the old ones left so I would have to read it or let there meter reader in twice a year .

Under the governments code of practice it says they can NOT force anyone to have a smart meter,
My main reason  to refuse it is because the radio frequency is close to WiFi frequency.  so it would be more 'mush' near to my WiFi signal. ;)


You Can Also Refuse To Have Other Smart Meters.  ;)
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: burakkucat on November 02, 2013, 07:53:48 PM
An excellent result Michael. Thank you for sharing.  :thumbs:
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: roseway on November 02, 2013, 10:36:16 PM
That's very interesting, thank you.
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: JGO on October 08, 2014, 04:57:02 PM
Tickmike,   Please can you quote chapter and verse.

I've just been told I can have one on the electricity, and the government web site say you don't have to
see https://www.gov.uk/smart-meters-how-they-work

BUT you could read it that the basic isn't optional, only the readout ?

I don't know if it is a transmitter or a data over powerline device - I don't like the idea of either !
 
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: Dray on October 08, 2014, 05:21:25 PM
Check out SSE's email address for the new meters

Email: smart@sse.com

 ;D
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: Ronski on October 08, 2014, 06:01:22 PM
We're having smart gas and electric meters fitted mid November, they use the mobile network to report back.

Doesn't bother me in the slightest, will save me from reading the meters and we even get  a new gadget to monitor usage.

They also open up the possibility to have cheaper electricity overnight,  like economy 7 but far more flexible, as the supplier will know exactly what you are using and when. I think they phone back every half hour. I'll be sure to monitor things like broadband and Wi-Fi,  but considering we have five mobiles in the house can't see it making any difference.
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: sevenlayermuddle on October 08, 2014, 06:48:48 PM
Unless anything has changed in the past few years, check out the reverse side of the letter for some nearly invisible grey on white print, that reads something like...

Quote
"By accepting a smart meter, you are deemed to be agreeing to a change in the T&C of supply such that we may disconnect your supply remotely without your consent." 

Not an exact quote as I no longer have the letter to hand.   But you must ask yourself why they should want to be granted that additional empowerment. :-\

Still, as long as it is one of our big energy companies in control, one of those pillars of society, we can have absolute confidence in their competence.  And that they would never dream of doing anything detrimental to their customers.   :lol:
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: c6em on October 08, 2014, 06:53:52 PM
That in my opinion the real long terms aim of smart meters - real time tariffs and real time monitoring.
So the tariff will change during the day and if you want to use a lot of whatever at a peak time - then you will have to pay a lot for it.
At the moment everything about energy is size for meeting the peak - if we as a country could even out usage over the day it would help hugely.


Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: Chrysalis on October 08, 2014, 07:39:15 PM
yeah as far as I am aware it is not law (yet) to have a smart meter.

c6em it also ends estimated bills, I guess is a fair amount of estimated bills below usage and people conveniently arent in when the meter guy knocks :)
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: kitz on October 08, 2014, 07:53:50 PM
Im bad..  I ignore things like that..  just as I ignore the automated phone calls for me to go read my meter... I put the phone down and wait until they send the little man round.
My meters are all external.. and it keeps someone in a job :)
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: Ronski on October 08, 2014, 10:37:36 PM
Unless anything has changed in the past few years, check out the reverse side of the letter for some nearly invisible grey on white print, that reads something like...

Quote
"By accepting a smart meter, you are deemed to be agreeing to a change in the T&C of supply such that we may disconnect your supply remotely without your consent." 

Not an exact quote as I no longer have the letter to hand.   But you must ask yourself why they should want to be granted that additional empowerment. :-\

Still, as long as it is one of our big energy companies in control, one of those pillars of society, we can have absolute confidence in their competence.  And that they would never dream of doing anything detrimental to their customers.   :lol:

Yes I do recollect reading something like that, and I presume it's for where people don't pay their bill, after all they wouldn't want to cut off the supply to someone who pays their bill, as they wouldn't make any money would they.
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: Dray on October 08, 2014, 10:56:54 PM
It gives the energy companies the ability to manage usage, say there's 10% bad boys using much more energy than everyone else then cutting them off will ease the load for the remaining 90%.
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: sevenlayermuddle on October 08, 2014, 11:50:38 PM

Yes I do recollect reading something like that, and I presume it's for where people don't pay their bill, after all they wouldn't want to cut off the supply to someone who pays their bill, as they wouldn't make any money would they.

They have always had right to remove supply for non payment.   With Smart Meters, it seems they want to be able to disconnect at their discretion, even for paid up customers, whenever they like.  Why?

My own best guess is that they want to be able to cope with critical shortages of supply - not by eliminating the shortages - but by providing incentives for 'essential' services such as hospitals, whatever, to pay more to the energy companies in return for continuity of supply.   That is a lot more profitable than simply increasing  capacity, even if a few dozen people die in hospitals that can't afford the extra,  or a few hundred freeze in their homes.

But surely nobody would get away with that in this day and age?  Well maybe, but remember, we are dealing with the big energy companies here.  All bets are off, then. :(
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: kitz on October 09, 2014, 12:10:38 AM
Did anyone see that BBC documentary a few months ago about United Utilities?   I didnt catch all of the series, but it was quite eye opening to see some of the things they had to cope with..  including playing cat and mouse game trying to cut off a business that owed them many thousands of pounds.
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: sevenlayermuddle on October 09, 2014, 01:00:42 AM
Did anyone see that BBC documentary a few months ago about United Utilities?   I didnt catch all of the series, but it was quite eye opening to see some of the things they had to cope with..  including playing cat and mouse game trying to cut off a business that owed them many thousands of pounds.


No sorry.

But I shall keep an eye out for it, might  would do me good to soften my bias against the big energy suppliers.  :D
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: Ronski on October 09, 2014, 07:13:42 AM
I take it 7LM that at some point you've had a big problem with energy suppliers?

We're with OVO,  which I don't think is a big energy company.
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: UncleUB on October 10, 2014, 10:25:41 PM
We had a water meter fitted in July..the best move I ever made,now saving me £250 a year.!!. It is one of those smart meters,no problem with it and no problem with wifi signal either  :)
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: sevenlayermuddle on October 10, 2014, 11:21:30 PM
We had a water meter fitted in July..the best move I ever made,now saving me £250 a year.!!. It is one of those smart meters,no problem with it and no problem with wifi signal either  :)

Water meters do often result in a cost saving, I have had one for decades,  though there can be 'surprises'.   

I know of two different people at first hand who have had leaks on their side of the supply, one metered, one not.   Both had to pay the cost of repairs which is fair enough as these are the rules.  But the metered customer was also billed many hundreds of pounds for the metered water that had escaped.    He got some allowance back but it was a struggle and, I think, 'discretionary'.   :o

Smart water meters are a different kettle of fish.  I hope you checked the small print, as to what you have empowered them to do at times of 'crisis'?

From...

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/earthnews/9219349/Smart-water-meters-to-be-installed-in-UK-homes.html
Quote
This would mean that customers are charged more during water shortages to encourage them to save water.
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: Ronski on October 10, 2014, 11:24:09 PM
We discovered a water meter had been fitted to our house some years ago, turned out it was fitted to the wrong house. Anyway we stayed on the old water rates, but I monitored our usage, after two years I decided we would be better off on the meter, and because it wasn't reading zero when we switched they back dated the bills to when it was fitted, we got about £350 back for those two years  ;D

7LM, don't you think he's saving more than enough to cover the remote possibility of increased charges due to times of crises?
Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: sevenlayermuddle on October 10, 2014, 11:50:05 PM
7LM, don't you think he's saving more than enough to cover the remote possibility of increased charges due to times of crises?

Hard to say really without pouring over the T&C but I guess we can be sure the Utility companies are of course cuddly and friendly, and would never dream of taking advantage of their customers.

But the main point is, he would make the same savings with a traditional dumb water meter.   Why take the risk by have a smart water meter instead?   Just in case they prove not to be so cuddly and friendly :D

Title: Re: You Can Refuse To Have A Smart Meter.
Post by: renluop on October 11, 2014, 09:41:59 AM
We had a water meter fitted in July..the best move I ever made,now saving me £250 a year.!!. It is one of those smart meters,no problem with it and no problem with wifi signal either  :)

Water meters do often result in a cost saving, I have had one for decades,  though there can be 'surprises'.   

I know of two different people at first hand who have had leaks on their side of the supply, one metered, one not.   Both had to pay the cost of repairs which is fair enough as these are the rules. But the metered customer was also billed many hundreds of pounds for the metered water that had escaped.    He got some allowance back but it was a struggle and, I think, 'discretionary'.   :o

Smart water meters are a different kettle of fish.  I hope you checked the small print, as to what you have empowered them to do at times of 'crisis'?

From...

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/earthnews/9219349/Smart-water-meters-to-be-installed-in-UK-homes.html
Quote
This would mean that customers are charged more during water shortages to encourage them to save water.
I had a leak a while back,and luckily insurance covered it. I cannot say that I had much trouble in getting a pretty accurate rebate; may be because I had kept records from which I could prove my case. Only hitch was that the after repair test reading was done in the end year holiday period. I challenged and was successful.

SLM! Thy're not all bad