Theoretically, a 'batt contact' fault should fail any test performed. Reality tells us different.
It all depends on the type of test being conducted (Low end Eclipse/Fast Test, or High end PQT), the amount of rogue voltage detected, and the parameter settings of the test system.
By way of an example I've had 12v battery contact show a 'LTOK' (Line test OK) result on Eclipse, but fail on the PQT.
Tie-pairs can indeed have the same fault conditions present that are prevalent in the network, but percentage wise, they would be in the very low percentages in comparison especially a 'batt contact'.
However, I'm not the engineer on site, and can only go off the info given to me by yourself. I have no idea what type of tests the previous engineer did, or what the total subsequent actions he performed ?.
I'm going to dip out now, and I refer you to the closing remark on my last post, on this thread. Cheers.