Chrysallis ..... I generally stay away from 'remote faulting' on a forum, especially speed-dips/increases as it could be absolutely anything causing them ?? If it's fluctuating attenuation, or something of that nature, then it's something that can be whittled down via a forum, but I wouldn't want know what to say regarding your issue without being on-site with my JDSU.
PS ..... regarding 'attainable speed' losses. Our systems (or the systems that I have access to) don't keep a log of 'attainable speeds'. Ergo, when I go about my faulting techniques, I work to synch speed only. It does sound feasible that it is crosstalk causing the problem, and if the other engineer proved this from dates and times, then I'd have to accept that.
I can't offer any other input i'm afraid, as I don't view 'attainable speeds' as part of my job.